• Banner 3
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 1

Welcome to John's Farms

John's Farms in Plainview, NY, is a one-stop shop for fresh seafood, meat, and produce. With a wide selection of meats, including steaks, lamb, and chicken, customers like Neila B. praise the store for its quality and personalized service. The butcher's attention to detail ensures customers get the cuts they desire, making shopping here a rewarding experience. Tracy K. marvels at the hustle and bustle of the seafood and deli sections, highlighting the quick turnover of fresh products. With a deli counter offering homemade selections and a variety of imported Italian goods, John's Farms is a gem for those seeking high-quality ingredients.

John's Farms: Reviews & Ratings

Amy W.
Amy W.

Fresh seafood ..veggie ..meat selections. Cash or debit only. Hope they have more option soon

Neila B.
Neila B.

Have shopped here on and off for the past 10 years. They have evolved to a store I have traveled over 30 minutes to get to. Their meats (steaks, lamb, chicken) is rightly priced and never a disappointment. I have asked the butcher (even on a very busy Saturday-the craziest day there) for specific steaks with the right amount of marbeling and have received or honestly been told why they don't have what I'm looking for. Today I was looking for a Veal chop and told that they don't have them. Other butcher's have tried to sell me whatever they have on the floor. If John's Farms has it, and it's not on the floor, they will get it for me and cut it the way I like it. The fish market is fast moving and I have eaten their Scallops, Lemon Sole, Salmon, Shrimp, Snapper, and much more and it's always been fresh. The deli has delicious prepared foods, store made cold cuts as well as boar's head, amazing cheeses and a great bakery. I go here specifically for produce; where else can you get fresh (not boxed) Arugula, fresh Culantro, and all produce equal to or better than anywhere else. This is a win-win and a trip for me every week, but totally worth it!

Peter K.
Peter K.

Old standby in Plainview for reasonable priced veggies fruits and meats. Need to be sharp eyed to avoid the suspect produce and fruits especially when lower priced. Meat section is well stocked, only place I know where they package 3 meat ground for Italian meatballs (beef, veal, pork) along with all kinds of beef pork chicken and other proteins. Their sliced meat deli counter is also great. Tons a customers and lots of choices including those home made selections. When I'm not shopping at Costco (too big, bulk items does not fit everyone's pantry), stop and shop; I go here.

Tracy K.
Tracy K.

John's Farms is the areas direct line from NYC's seafood and produce points to Plainview. Its all hustle and bustle and super fast turnover of the freshest seafood, deli and ready to eat produce on the Island. Tucked into a small strip center on Old Country Rd, just west of Rt. 135, and easy stop off for anyone travelling near that or the LIE. Just drop down. You will see too many cars and wonder if you should drive into the busy parking lot. Everyone being patient as parking spots open up within a minute or so. But not often an empty one. Lol! Inside what was once a small fresh produce / fish market / deli has evolved most recently to having hot food right up front and also some super delicious bread in from Brooklyn, They also have bakery in from Francesco's so cookies, cake all there at the front to grab and go. The deli and seafood counters, you take a number, Saturday afternoons are the busiest so pick a mid week, or go early or late if time is key. Otherwise, just enjoy the best selection of seafood, deli that is always Long Island's freshest. Super values on grapes, tomatoes, berries, and all produce. Fruit is often ready to eat the same week. So don't let it sit. Imported Italian Cheese (sharp provolone) Deli (soppressata), Panettone, even Italian chocolate, candy, cookies at Christmas and Easter are here. They are in the window by the registers, so you sometimes have to run over while on line to get them.. it causes delays when I am on line and see new Panettones. Lol! At holiday time, I bring them to friends/family. They are an odd, somewhat dry spongy cake with different flavors, chocolate, lemon, hazelnut, or plain. They become a habit. If you really want to score a hit with sandwiches, grab a huge over-sized Italian Bastone bread in from Brooklyn, and a jar of roasted peppers to add to your deli items. Everyone asks me to get that bread again. And I do! If its there. Squeeze to see which is freshest.. they last only a few days. Use right away. Delicious Italian herbal tea can be found on the shelves at the bottom by the deli. An olive bar is near the deli. Number one, is the wild caught shrimp, jumbo shrimp, wild caught salmon, sea bass, wild caught anything else. Its there read the labels for which is which. Catfish sometimes appears and goes fast. Bluefish, Mussels, Clams, Scallops sea and bay sized, etc. They have flounder rolled with seafood stuffing you can just cover and bake easily. My mother gets her spring plants here every new season. Rows of colorful flowering plants even some tomato plants to kick off the season. She usually gets extra and gives a few to me or the neighbors.

Location

  • John's Farms
    601 Old Country Rd Plainview, NY 11803 Hotline: (516) 933-1447

John's Farms, located in Plainview, NY, is a hidden gem that offers a wide range of fresh seafood, meat, and produce. This meat shop, grocery store, and deli has become a favorite among customers for its high-quality meats, delicious prepared foods, and fresh produce.

Customers rave about the attentive and knowledgeable staff, particularly the butchers who go above and beyond to ensure customers get exactly what they're looking for. The meat selection is extensive, with options like steaks, lamb, chicken, and even a unique 3-meat ground mix for Italian meatballs.

The seafood market is fast-moving, offering a variety of options like scallops, salmon, shrimp, snapper, and more. Customers appreciate the freshness and quality of the seafood available at John's Farms. The deli counter is also a standout, offering a selection of store-made cold cuts, boar's head products, cheeses, and a great bakery selection.

One customer described John's Farms as their go-to spot for produce, praising the freshness and variety available. From fresh arugula to culantro, the produce section at John's Farms has everything you need to create delicious meals at home.

Overall, John's Farms is a bustling hub of activity, with fast turnover of the freshest seafood, deli items, and produce on Long Island. Whether you're looking for a quick bite to eat or ingredients for a gourmet meal, John's Farms has you covered. Make sure to stop by and experience all that this hidden gem has to offer.